Set Equation: Union

Theorem
Let $A$ and $B$ be sets.

Consider the set equality:
 * $A \cup X = B$

The solution set of this is given by:
 * $X = \begin {cases} \O & : A \nsubseteq B \\ \set {\paren {B \setminus A} \cup Y: Y \subseteq A} & : \text {otherwise} \end {cases}$

Proof
In the first case, $A$ is a not a subset of $B$.

So there exists an $x \in A$ such that $x \notin B$.

By the definition of union:


 * $\forall x: x \in A \implies x \in A \cup X$

Hence the solution set is empty.

In the second case, suppose $A$ is a subset of $B$.

In particular, suppose $A$ is a subset of $B$, and $B$ is the empty set.

By Subset of Empty Set:


 * $A = \O$.

Then, :

Hence, by Empty Set is Subset of All Sets:


 * $X = \O \in \set {\paren {B \setminus A} \cup Y: Y \subseteq A}$

as required.

Suppose $A$ is a subset of $B$ and $B$ is non-empty.

By definition of a subset:
 * $A \subseteq B \iff \forall x: \paren {x \in A \implies x \in B}$

Then, and the axiom of extension:


 * $\forall x: \paren {x \in A \cup X \iff x \in B }$

It follows that:


 * $\forall x: x \notin B \implies \neg{\paren{\paren {x \in A \implies x \in B} \land \paren {x \in A \cup X \iff x \in B} } }$

By Proof by Contraposition:
 * $\forall x: \paren {x \in A \implies x \in B} \land \paren {x \in A \cup X \iff x \in B} \implies x \in B$

Then:


 * $\forall x: \paren {x \in A \implies x \in B} \land \paren {x \in A \cup X \iff x \in B} \implies x \in \paren{\paren{B \cup A } \setminus A }$

By Set is Subset of Itself and the definition of existential quantifier:
 * $\forall x: \paren {x \in A \implies x \in B} \land \paren {x \in A \cup X \iff x \in B} \implies \exists A \subseteq A: x \in \paren{\paren{B \cup A } \setminus A }$

Then, let $Y \subseteq A$ be arbitrary, such that:


 * $\forall x: \paren {x \in A \implies x \in B} \land \paren {x \in A \cup X \iff x \in B} \implies \exists Y \subseteq A: x \in \paren{\paren{B \cup Y } \setminus A }$

By definition of set union:


 * $\forall x: \paren {x \in A \implies x \in B} \land \paren {x \in A \cup X \iff x \in B} \implies \exists Y \subseteq A: \paren{x \in Y \setminus A } \lor \paren{x \in B \setminus A }$

By Set is Subset of Union:


 * $\forall x: \paren {x \in A \implies x \in B} \land \paren {x \in A \cup X \iff x \in B} \implies \exists Y \subseteq A: \paren{x \in Y \setminus A } \lor \paren{x \in Y } \lor \paren{x \in B \setminus A }$

By Union is Commutative:


 * $\forall x: \paren {x \in A \implies x \in B} \land \paren {x \in A \cup X \iff x \in B} \implies \exists Y \subseteq A: \paren{x \in Y \setminus A } \lor \paren{x \in B \setminus A } \lor \paren{x \in Y }$

By definition of set complement:


 * $\forall x: \paren {x \in A \implies x \in B} \land \paren {x \in A \cup X \iff x \in B} \implies \exists Y \subseteq A: \paren{\paren{\paren {x \in Y } \land \paren{x \notin A } } \lor \paren{x \in B \land x \notin A } \lor \paren{x \in Y } }$

By Double Negation/Double Negation Elimination/Proof Rule:


 * $\forall x: \paren {x \in A \implies x \in B} \land \paren {x \in A \cup X \iff x \in B} \implies \exists Y \subseteq A: \paren{\neg \paren{\neg \paren{\paren {x \in Y } \land \paren{x \notin A } } } \lor \paren{x \in B \land x \notin A } \lor \paren{x \in Y } }$

By definition of implication:


 * $\forall x: \paren {x \in A \implies x \in B} \land \paren {x \in A \cup X \iff x \in B} \implies \exists Y \subseteq A: \paren{\neg \paren{\paren {x \in Y } \land \paren{x \notin A } } \implies \paren{x \in B \land x \notin A } \lor \paren{x \in Y } }$

By De Morgan's Laws for Set Complement of Intersection:


 * $\forall x: \paren {x \in A \implies x \in B} \land \paren {x \in A \cup X \iff x \in B} \implies \exists Y \subseteq A: \paren{ \neg \paren{\paren {x \in Y } \lor \paren{x \in A } } \implies \paren{x \in B \land x \notin A } \lor \paren{x \in Y } }$

By definition of set complement:


 * $\forall x: \paren {x \in A \implies x \in B} \land \paren {x \in A \cup X \iff x \in B} \implies \exists Y \subseteq A: \paren{ \neg \paren{\paren {x \in Y } \lor \paren{x \in A } } \implies \paren{x \in B \setminus A } \lor \paren{x \in Y } }$

By definition of implication:


 * $\forall x: \paren {x \in A \implies x \in B} \land \paren {x \in A \cup X \iff x \in B} \implies \exists Y \subseteq A: \paren{\paren{x \in Y \implies x \in A} \implies \paren{x \in B \setminus A } \lor \paren{x \in Y } }$

By definition of set union:


 * $\forall x: \paren {x \in A \implies x \in B} \land \paren {x \in A \cup X \iff x \in B} \implies \exists Y \subseteq A: \paren{\paren{x \in Y \implies x \in A} \implies x \in \set{ \paren{ B \setminus A } \cup Y } }$

By definition of subset:


 * $\forall x: \paren {x \in A \implies x \in B} \land \paren {x \in A \cup X \iff x \in B} \implies \exists Y \subseteq A: \paren{ x \in Y \implies x \in \set{ \paren{ B \setminus A } \cup Y } }$

By definition of set-builder notation:


 * $\forall x: \paren {x \in A \implies x \in B} \land \paren {x \in A \cup X \iff x \in B} \implies x \in \set {\paren{B \setminus A} \cup Y :Y \subseteq A }$

Hence:
 * $\forall X: A \subseteq B \land \paren {A \cup X = B} \implies X = \set {\paren {B \setminus A} \cup Y :Y \subseteq A }$

as required.