Existence of Unique Subsemigroup Generated by Subset/Proof 1

Existence
First, we prove that such a subsemigroup exists.

Let $\mathbb S$ be the set of all subsemigroups of $S$ which contain $X$.

$\mathbb S \ne \O$ because $S$ is itself a subsemigroup of $S$ (trivial), and thus $S \in \mathbb S$.

Let $T$ be the intersection of all the elements of $\mathbb S$.

By Intersection of Subsemigroups, $T$ is the largest element of $\mathbb S$ contained in each element of $\mathbb S$.

Thus $T$ is a subsemigroup of $S$.

Since $\forall x \in \mathbb S: X \subseteq x$, we see that $X \subseteq T$, so $T \in \mathbb S$.

Smallest
Now to show that $T$ is the smallest such subsemigroup.

If any $K \le S: X \subseteq K$, then $K \in \mathbb S$ and therefore $T \subseteq K$.

So $T$ is the smallest subsemigroup of $S$ containing $X$.

Uniqueness
Now we show that $T$ is unique.

Suppose $\exists T_1, T_2 \in \mathbb S$ such that $T_1$ and $T_2$ were two such smallest subsemigroups containing $X$.

Then, by the definition of smallest, each would be equal in size.

, suppose that $T_1$ is not a subset of $T_2$.

Then their intersection (by definition containing $X$) would be a subsemigroup smaller than $T_1$.

Hence $T_1$ would not be the smallest.

Therefore each must be the subset of each other.

By definition of set equality, they must be the same set.

So the smallest subsemigroup, whose existence we have proved above, is unique.