Axiom of Archimedes/Variant

Theorem
Let $x$ and $y$ be a natural numbers.

Then there exists a natural number $n$ such that:
 * $n x \ge y$

Proof
there exists $x, y \in \N$ such that $n x < y$ for every natural number $n$.

Consider the set $S$, defined as:


 * $S := \set {y - n x: n \in \N}$

By hypothesis, $S$ contains only natural numbers.

By the Well-Ordering Principle, $S$ contains a smallest element, $y - m x$ for example.

But $y - \paren {m + 1} x$ is also in $S$, as $S$ contains all natural numbers of this form.

Furthermore, we have:
 * $y - \paren {m + 1} x = \paren {y - m x} - x < y - m x$

But this contradicts our assertion that $y - m x$ is the smallest element of $S$.

This assertion originated from the assumption that there exists $x, y \in \N$ such that $n x < y$ for every natural number $n$.

Hence that assumption cannot hold.

Hence the result by proof by Contradiction.