Ladies' Diary/Dutchmen's Three Wives/Proof 1
Puzzle
- There came $3$ dutchmen of my acquaintance to see me, being lately married;
- they brought their wives with them.
- The men's names were Hendrick, Claas, and Cornelius;
- the women's Geertrick, Catriin, and Anna;
- but I forget the name of each man's wife.
- They told me that they had been at market, to buy hogs;
- each person bought as many hogs as they gave shillings for each hog;
- Hendrick bought $23$ hogs more than Catriin,
- and Claas bought $11$ more than Geertrick;
- likewise, each man laid out $3$ guineas more than his wife.
- I desire to know the name of each man's wife.
Solution
Note that a guinea is $21$ shillings.
- Hendrick bought $32$ hogs and his wife Anna bought $31$
- Claas bought $12$ hogs and his wife Catriin bought $9$
- Cornelius bought $8$ hogs and his wife Geertrick bought $1$.
Proof
Let the number of hogs bought by any one of the women be $x$.
Let the number of hogs bought by her husband be $x + n$.
Then:
- the money paid by the woman is $x^2$ shillings
- the money paid by her husband is $\paren {x + n}^2$ shillings
There are $21$ shillings to the guinea, so:
- $\paren {x + n}^2 = x^2 + 63$
and so:
- $x = \dfrac {63 - n^2} {2 n}$
We see that in order for $x$ to be an integer it is necessary for $n$ to be odd.
Now we can plug various values of $n$ and see where this gets us.
It turns out by trying various $n$ that $3$ such values work, as follows:
If $n = 1$ then $x = 31$ and $x + n = 32$
If $n = 3$ then $x = 9$ and $x + n = 12$
If $n = 7$ then $x = 1$ and $x + n = 8$.
Now we can see that:
- Hendrick bought $32$ hogs and Catriin bought $9$ hogs
- Claas bought $12$ hogs and Geertrick bought $1$ hog
and the allocation of men with their wives then becomes apparent.
$\blacksquare$
Historical Note
This proof of the problem of the Dutchmen and their $3$ wives is reported as being the work of J. Hill, who may well have been the same John Hill who published Arithmetick, Both in the Theory and Practice in $1716$.
Sources
- 1992: David Wells: Curious and Interesting Puzzles ... (previous) ... (next): The Ladies' Diary or Woman's Almanac, $\text {1704}$ – $\text {1841}$: $141$