# Point in Plane is Constructible iff Coordinates in Extension of Degree Power of 2

## Theorem

Let $\CC$ be a Cartesian plane.

Let $S$ be a set of points in $\CC$.

Let $F$ be the smallest field containing all the coordinates of the points in $S$.

Let $P = \tuple {a, b}$ be a point in $\CC$.

Then:

- $P$ is constructible from $S$ using a compass and straightedge construction

- the coordinates of $P$ are contained in a finite extension $K$ of $F$ whose degree is given by:
- $\index K F = 2^m$

- for some $m \in \Z_{\ge 0}$.

## Proof

A point $P$ is constructed in a compass and straightedge construction from one of $3$ basic operations:

- $(1): \quad$ the intersection of $2$ straight lines

- $(2): \quad$ the intersection of a straight line and the circumference of a circle

- $(3): \quad$ the intersection of the circumferences of $2$ circle.

Let $A$, $B$, $C$ and $D$ be points in $S$.

In case $(1)$, the equations defining the straight lines $AB$ and $CD$ are polynomials of degree $1$.

Hence the coordinates of $P$ can be found by solving the linear simultaneous equations defining $AB$ and $CD$.

It follows that the solution is in $F$.

$\Box$

In case $(2)$:

- the equation defining the circle whose center is at $A$ and whose radius is $AB$ is of the form $x^2 + y^2 + 2 f x + 2 g y + c = 0$, where $c, f, g \in F$.

while:

- the equation defining the straight line $CD$ is a polynomial of degree $1$.

The $x$-coordinate of $P$ is then the root of a quadratic equation with coefficients in $F$.

The $y$-coordinate of $P$ is then found by solving a linear equation.

Thus the coordinates of $P$ are elements of either a field extension of $F$ of degree $2$ or of $F$ itself.

In case $(3)$:

- the equation defining the circle whose center is at $A$ and whose radius is $AB$ is of the form $x^2 + y^2 + 2 f x + 2 g y + c = 0$, where $c, f, g \in F$

- the equation defining the circle whose center is at $C$ and whose radius is $CD$ is of the form $x^2 + y^2 + 2 f' x + 2 g' y + c' = 0$, where $c', f', g' \in F$.

The solution of these equations is the same as the solution of either circle and the straight line $2 \paren {f - f'} x + 2 \paren {g - g'} y + \paren {c - c'} = 0$, which is the same as case $(2)$.

We have that the coordinates of the various points belong to the field $F = F_0$, say.

Suppose $P$ is constructed using $k$ of the basic constructions $(1)$, $(2)$ and $(3)$.

Let $F_i$ be the smallest field containing all the points so far obtained by $i$ such constructions, for $i = 1, 2, \ldots, k$.

Either $F_i = F_{i - 1}$ or $F_i$ is an finite extension of $F_i$ of degree $2$.

Thus for each $i$, either:

- $\index {F_i} {F_{i - 1} } = 1$

or:

- $\index {F_i} {F_{i - 1} } = 2$

Therefore:

- $\index {F_k} {F_0} = \index {F_k} {F_{k - 1} } \index {F_{k - 1} } {F_{k - 2} } \dotsm {F_1} {F_0} = 2^m$

where $0 \le m \le k$.

Hence the result.

$\blacksquare$

## Sources

- 1969: C.R.J. Clapham:
*Introduction to Abstract Algebra*... (previous) ... (next): Chapter $8$: Field Extensions: $\S 40$. Construction with Ruler and Compasses: Theorem $75$