Time when Hour Hand and Minute Hand at Right Angle

From ProofWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Theorem

Let the time of day be such that the hour hand and minute hand are at a right angle to each other.

Then the time happens $22$ times in every $12$ hour period:

when the minute hand is $15$ minutes ahead of the hour hand
when the minute hand is $15$ minutes behind of the hour hand.


In the first case, this happens at $09:00$ and every $1$ hour, $5$ minutes and $27 . \dot 2 \dot 7$ seconds after

In the second case, this happens at $03:00$ and every $1$ hour, $5$ minutes and $27 . \dot 2 \dot 7$ seconds after.


Thus the times are, to the nearest second:

$\begin {array} 09:00:00 & 03:00:00 \\ 10:05:27 & 04:05:27 \\ 11:10:55 & 05:10:55 \\ 12:16:22 & 06:16:22 \\ 13:21:49 & 07:21:49 \\ 14:27:16 & 08:27:16 \\ 15:32:44 & 09:32:44 \\ 16:38:11 & 10:38:11 \\ 17:43:38 & 11:43:38 \\ 18:49:05 & 12:49:05 \\ 19:54:33 & 13:54:33 \\ \end{array}$

and times $12$ hours different.


Proof

Obviously the hands are at right angles at $3$ and $9$ o'clock.

Thus we only need to show that the angle between the hands will be the same after every $1$ hour, $5$ minutes and $27 . \dot 2 \dot 7$ seconds.

Note that:

\(\ds 1 h \ 5 m \ 27. \dot 2 \dot 7 s\) \(=\) \(\ds 65 m \ 27 \tfrac {27}{99} s\)
\(\ds \) \(=\) \(\ds 65 m \ 27 \tfrac 3 {11} s\)
\(\ds \) \(=\) \(\ds 65 m \ \frac {300} {11} s\)
\(\ds \) \(=\) \(\ds 65 m + \frac 5 {11} m\)
\(\ds \) \(=\) \(\ds \frac {720} {11} m\)
\(\ds \) \(=\) \(\ds \frac {12} {11} h\)

In $\dfrac {12} {11}$ hours:

The minute hand has rotated $\dfrac {12} {11} \times 360^\circ$
The hour hand has rotated $\dfrac {12} {11} \times 30^\circ$

Thus the angle between the hands has changed by:

\(\ds \frac {12} {11} \times 360^\circ - \frac {12} {11} \times 30^\circ\) \(=\) \(\ds \frac {12} {11} \times 330^\circ\)
\(\ds \) \(=\) \(\ds 360^\circ\)

which is a full rotation.

Hence after $\dfrac {12} {11}$ hours the angle between the hands would remain unchanged.

$\blacksquare$